Property Insurance

Auto Insurance Appraisals (Property and Third-Party Liability) (2002)

June 24, 2002

12 min read

Introduction:

In the High Court of Justice case regarding appraisers (for a summary on our firm’s website) Click here) It was ruled that the Insurance Commissioner has the authority to take steps to mitigate conflicts of interest in the work of auto insurance appraisers.

Following the High Court of Justice ruling, the Insurance Commissioner implemented a comprehensive arrangement that transfers the responsibility for appraising damaged insured vehicles to independent appraisers.

The regulation requires insurance companies to compile a list of independent appraisers for each district. In-house appraisers may not be included on the list. An insured person whose vehicle has been damaged may select an independent appraiser from the list at his or her discretion.

A mechanism was also established for a expedited appeal of a disputed assessment before an arbitrator.

The regulation establishes rules designed to prevent insurers, agents, policyholders, repair shops, or any other relevant party from influencing the appraiser’s independent professional judgment.

The agreement also contains provisions regarding disclosure and other operational rules.

The agreement took effect on January 1, 2003, for a period of three years.

The following are the instructions in the circular:

The State of Israel

Ministry of Finance—Capital Markets, Insurance, and Savings Division

14 Tammuz 5762

June 24, 2002

Insurance Circular 2002/7

Auto Insurance Appraisals (Property and Third-Party Liability)

Introduction

The issue of auto insurance appraisals was brought before the Supreme Court in a petition to the High Court of Justice (7721/96).

In the Supreme Court’s decision dated April 15, 2001, the following was stated, among other things:

      1. "The insurance company may determine its liability through its own employees. It is appropriate for this to be done by experts in the field. Therefore, there is no logical or legal basis preventing an insurance company from employing auto appraisers as company employees to assist it in determining its liability. This is also required by the principle of freedom of contract." [Section 32]

2. "However, the situation is different if the home appraiser is the sole appraiser determining the damage assessment, and that assessment is also intended to be binding on the insured. In such a situation, the appraiser owes a duty of loyalty to both the insurance company and the insured. This constitutes a conflict of interest and is therefore impermissible." [Section 37]

3. "The Insurance Commissioner has the authority, under the Insurance Supervision Law, to remedy the deficiency. She must exercise this authority to establish an arrangement that properly balances, in accordance with the purpose of the law, the need to protect policyholders and the right of insurance companies to employ in-house appraisers." [Section 41]

In light of the Supreme Court’s ruling, the following arrangement is intended to minimize conflicts of interest in the work of auto insurance appraisers by stipulating that the appraisal shall be conducted by an external appraiser (as defined below), and that this appraisal shall be the final and binding one.

Under the current system, many insurance companies employ in-house appraisers who determine the amount of damage after an insured vehicle is involved in an accident.

In the past, the practice was for the insured to choose, usually through his or her insurance agent, an appraiser of his or her choice to assess the damage to his or her vehicle.

Both now and in the past, either party could request and obtain a counter-appraisal on its own behalf. However, in practice, the first appraisal conducted is usually the only one, and therefore the appraisal currently being prepared by the in-house appraiser is, in most cases, the definitive one.

The appraiser’s role requires him to exercise objective judgment. This aspect of the appraiser’s role may be compromised, for example, when the insurer employs the appraiser, or when only one party selects the appraiser (the insurer or the insured), in which case the appraiser may feel obligated exclusively to the party that selected him or her.

The following arrangement is based on a mechanism designed to ensure that the appraiser selected to assess the damage will be objective. This objective is achieved through a combination of, on the one hand, the insured’s right to select an external appraiser from a sufficiently broad list of external appraisers, and, on the other hand, the insurance company’s right to select the external appraisers to be included on the list. At the same time, a rapid appeal mechanism has been established for both the insurer and the insured. The circular also sets forth provisions that expand the disclosure provided to the insured by requiring that the proposed amendment and the appraisal be delivered to the insured. In formulating the arrangement, the cost, efficiency, and speed of the process were also taken into account, as these are also important interests of the insured.

The Agreement

1. Definitions

"Proposed Amendment" – A preliminary damage assessment performed by the appraiser before or during the vehicle's repair.

"Workday" – Every day except for days of rest or official holidays in the State of Israel.

"District" – As stated in the notice regarding the division of the country into districts and sub-districts and the descriptions of their boundaries (Official Gazette, 5717, p. 761), the Northern District may be merged with the Haifa District, and the Central District may be merged with the Tel Aviv District.

"Insurance Group" – Insurance companies, including a parent insurance company and a sister company as defined in the Regulations on the Supervision of Insurance Business (Methods of Investing an Insurer’s Capital and Funds and Managing Its Liabilities), 5761–2001, and including any subsidiary or affiliated company as defined in the Securities Law, 5728–1968.

"Mole"– A final damage estimate prepared by the appraiser after the vehicle has been repaired.

"Appraiser" – Any person listed in the Register of Appraisers, as defined in the Commodities and Services Supervision Order (Vehicle Appraisers), 5740–1980.

"Another appraiser" – Any appraiser who is not an in-house appraiser or an external appraiser.

"Home Appraiser" – An appraiser who may be in a conflict of interest due to a special relationship with the insurer, including:

      1. An appraiser who is an employee of the insurance group;

2. An appraiser whose total income from appraisals and other business dealings with insurers exceeds 25% is considered part of the insurance group;

3. An appraisal firm in which the insurance group holds more than 5% of the means of control.

"External Appraiser" – An appraiser who is not a in-house appraiser and is included in the list of external appraisers as defined in Section 3.

A corporation or appraisal firm is treated the same as an individual appraiser. A corporation includes a company, a partnership, or any other business entity.

2. Assessment of Damages Following the Occurrence of an Insured Event

The insurer’s efforts to settle the claim shall be conducted in good faith and shall aim for a prompt, fair, and just settlement of the claim in a manner that minimizes, as much as possible, the insured’s costs and inconvenience.

      1. After an insured event occurs and before the damage to the vehicle is repaired, the insured shall select an independent appraiser from the list of independent appraisers, as detailed below, to assess the damage to the vehicle.

2. The repair estimate and the appraisal by the independent appraiser shall be the final repair estimate and appraisal, unless the insurer submits in writing a counter-estimate or counter-appraisal (from any appraiser) and has notified the arbitrator of its intention to challenge the repair proposal or appraisal, as detailed below, no later than one business day after the external appraiser prepared the repair proposal or one week after the appraisal was submitted to the insurer.

3. The insured shall be entitled to appeal the proposed adjustment or the external appraiser’s assessment, provided that he or she has submitted a counterproposal and notified the insurer of his or her intention to appeal prior to the vehicle’s repair, or has submitted a counter-assessment no later than one week after the external appraiser’s assessment was delivered to him.

4. In an appeal against an external appraiser’s assessment before an arbitrating appraiser, the appeal may be limited only to those matters not specified in the proposed amendment.

5. The insurer shall bear the full cost of the external appraiser's fees.

6. Alternatively, the insured may choose another appraiser. This appraisal shall not be the determining appraisal as specified in Section 2(b) above. Nothing in this section shall derogate from the insured’s right to receive reimbursement for the other appraiser’s fees, to the extent that the insured is entitled to such reimbursement.

7. An insurer, insurance agent, adjuster, or repair shop shall not grant or receive a commission or any other benefit—including, for this purpose, discounts on deductibles, the provision of a replacement vehicle, and the like—in connection with or in the course of the process of selecting an independent adjuster.

3. List of External Appraisers

      1. The insurer shall prepare a list of appraisers for each district, ensuring adequate geographic distribution (hereinafter referred to as “the list” or “the list of external appraisers”). This list, as updated from time to time as described below, will be provided to the insured upon the occurrence of an insured event and immediately upon the insured’s request at any time, and will also be available to the public, including through the insurer’s website.

2. The list shall include at least one appraiser for every 3,500 vehicles that were covered by auto (property) insurance with the insurer on the last day of the previous year. Appraisers may be added at any time.

3. In any case, the number of appraisers in each district shall not be less than five.

4. An insurer may prepare additional lists of external appraisers for vehicles that are not any of the following: private or commercial vehicles weighing up to 4 metric tons, or motorcycles. These lists may also be organized on a basis other than by district, provided that each list includes at least five appraisers.

5. An insurer wishing to register an external appraiser on its list must obtain from the appraiser a certified accountant’s statement attesting that the appraiser’s total income of any kind from the insurer’s insurance group in each of the two preceding fiscal years did not exceed 25% of his total income from appraisals and other business dealings with insurers in the relevant year.

6. The list of external appraisers shall be updated once a year, no later than April 30, based on the number of vehicles insured with the insurer as of December 31 of the preceding year. Notwithstanding the foregoing, an insurer may remove an appraiser from the list during the year, subject to Section 3(b) above, provided that the matter has been discussed with the insurer’s internal auditor, a reasoned notice was provided to the appraiser 21 days prior to his removal from the list, and he was given an adequate opportunity to present his case. Concurrently with the notice to the appraiser, the insurer shall report the appraiser’s removal to the Advisory Council established pursuant to the Insurance Business Supervision Law, 5741-1981.

4. Appraiser's Decision

      1. The Association of Insurance Companies and the Association of Appraisers shall compile a list of arbitrating appraisers who will assess the damage in any case of a dispute between two repair proposals or two appraisals, as mentioned above. The list will include a reasonable number of appraisers with adequate geographic representation, and it will be made available to the public, including via the Internet.

2. If the insured or the insurer notifies of their intention to appeal the proposed adjustment or assessment as set forth in Sections 2(b) or 2(c), the arbitrator shall be selected at random from the list of arbitrators. The arbitrator shall not be an in-house or external appraiser of the relevant insurer.

3. The arbitrator shall render his opinion no later than one business day after receiving the proposed amendments or three days after receiving the appraisals from the two appraisers.

4. The arbitrator’s fee shall be determined in advance. The arbitrator shall also determine how the arbitrator’s fee and the cost of the insured’s counterproposal or counterassessment are to be divided between the insurer and the insured, depending on the outcome of the appeal. The cost of the insurer’s counterproposal or counterassessment shall be borne by the insurer.

5. Impact on Appraisers

An insurer, insurance agent, insured, repair shop, or any other relevant party shall not influence (beyond the provision of relevant information) the independent professional judgment of an appraiser who prepares an appraisal for an insured, including:

      1. The appraiser shall not be subject to instructions that restrict his or her professional judgment, including when determining whether a vehicle is a "total loss," even if the gross damage to the vehicle is less than 60 percent.

2. The appraiser shall not be assigned duties that are inconsistent with his or her role as an appraiser, and in particular:

        1) He shall not be required to refer insured persons to authorized repair shops or to certain other repair shops;

2) He will not be required to sign vehicle inspection forms after repairs.

3. An insurer shall not use appraisal software that does not allow the appraiser to choose between several types of replacement parts.

4. A recommendation regarding the required number of working hours or a specific rate shall not preclude the appraiser from exercising professional judgment.

5. If an appraiser changes details in a report prepared by an appraiser employed by him or otherwise subordinate to him, the appraisal report shall be signed by the appraiser who initiated the changes to the report.

6. Examining the average claim costs of all appraisal reports prepared by the same appraiser, without analyzing that appraiser’s performance in detail using professional statistical methods, will be considered an impermissible influence by the insurer on the appraiser’s professional judgment.

7. No insurance agent, auto repair shop, appraiser, or any other party shall pay any commission of any kind, including any benefit, to one another in connection with this agreement.

6. Disclosure

      1. An insurer shall include in the auto insurance policy a detailed description of the mechanism set forth in sections 2, 3, 4, and 6(b) of this circular.

2. Prior to the vehicle’s repair, the insurer shall provide the insured with all repair estimates it has received. In addition, the insurer shall provide the insured with the final appraiser’s report shortly after the report is completed. These reports shall include, as applicable, among other things:

        1) Description and identification of the vehicle subject to the assessment.

2) A detailed description of the physical damage caused by the insured event, including a verbal description of the damage.

3) A financial assessment of the damages, including depreciation, resulting from the insured event, and the method of calculating them, including:

          * The replacement parts to be used to repair the damage.

* Parts type: New (original), New (other), Used (original), Used (other).

* Prices of replacement parts.

* The number of hours required to repair the damage.

* Hourly rate.

* The method for calculating the vehicle's value for depreciation purposes and the method for calculating depreciation.

* How to calculate the vehicle's value in the event of a total loss.

4) Any additional factual information on which the assessment is based.

5) The appraiser’s details and signature, in accordance with the provisions of the law.

7. Reporting Instructions

Once a year, no later than April 30, an insurer shall submit the following information to the Insurance Commissioner:

      1. The number of insurance claims in the calendar year preceding the reporting date;

2. The number of appeals filed by the insurer and their outcomes (including a breakdown by policy number);

3. The number of appeals filed by policyholders and their outcomes (including a breakdown by policy number);

4. The number of appraisers removed from the insurer’s list of external appraisers during the year.

8. Application Instructions

      1. For the purposes of implementing the provisions of this circular, an insurer shall submit to the Commissioner, no later than December 1, 2002, the number of vehicles insured under its motor vehicle (property) insurance as of June 30, 2002, and the list of independent appraisers it has compiled for January 1, 2003.

2. The appeal mechanism referred to in Section 4 and the procedures for its implementation shall be submitted to the Insurance Commissioner for approval no later than October 1, 2002.

Scope

      1. The provisions of this circular shall apply to insurance policies in the motor (property) insurance sector, and shall also apply in full with respect to third-party claims in any case where the injured party has selected an independent adjuster from the list of independent adjusters provided by the insurer of the party at fault. The mere selection of an external appraiser by a third party does not, in and of itself, determine the insurer’s liability.

2. The provisions of this circular shall not apply to an insured who owns at least 40 vehicles, if the insured has chosen to opt out of the circular’s application under the insurance policy.

First

The provisions of this circular will be in effect from January 1, 2003, through December 31, 2006, and will be reviewed again toward the end of that period.

Transitional Provisions

Notes

Date of Publication of the List of External Appraisers

The list may also include appraisers who, according to the provisions of this circular, were in-house appraisers as of November 30, 2002, including appraisers who ceased to be employees of the insurance company by that date.

1.1.03

An accountant’s certification will be required for the appraiser as specified in Section 3(e), and the review of the appraiser’s income will cover the first six months of 2003.

31.8.03

An accountant’s certification will be required for the appraiser as specified in Section 3(e), and the review of the appraiser’s income will apply only to the year 2003.

30.4.04

Eyal, age three

Insurance Commissioner

Contact Us

Subscribe to the Newsletter

We invite you to sign up for our website updates. Registration is free. The updates will be sent directly to your email inbox. We’d love to hear your feedback on the newsletter’s content via email. office@kalir.co.il