A client from the Haim Kalir & Co. website'
The State of Israel
Ministry of Finance – Capital Markets, Insurance, and Savings Division
24 Cheshvan 5770
November 11, 2009
Circular to Agents and Consultants, October 3, 2009
Category: General
Pursuant to my authority under Section 2(b) of the Financial Services Supervision (Insurance) Law, 5741-1981 (hereinafter— Supervision Act), pursuant to Section 39(b) of the Financial Services Supervision (Provident Funds) Law, 5765-2005 (hereinafter— The Provident Funds Law), and after consulting with the advisory committee, I hereby order as follows:
1. General
A client who consults an insurance agent regarding the identity of a service provider—such as a mechanic, attorney, appraiser, or doctor—expects to receive a professional recommendation from the agent. Therefore, an insurance agent’s engagement with a service provider—where the agent refers a client in exchange for compensation or another benefit—is inconsistent with the duties of loyalty and care to which the insurance agent is bound, as well as with the client’s expectations of the agent. Such an arrangement raises concerns about a conflict of interest between the agent’s personal interest and the client’s interest.
Insurance Circular 2007-1-8, "Automobile Insurance Appraisals (Property and Third-Party Liability),' prohibits insurance agents from receiving a commission or any other benefit in connection with the selection of an appraiser for a client. This circular extends the prohibition set forth in the circular "Motor Vehicle Insurance Appraisals (Property and Third-Party Liability)" to other service providers as well.
2. Definitions
In this circular—
"Contract" – An insurance policy or the bylaws of a provident fund.
"Contract Formation" – Entering into an insurance contract or enrolling as a member of a provident fund, including any negotiations leading up to such actions.
"Service Provider" – A person who provides a service or product to a customer for the purpose of entering into or performing a contract, including for the purpose of settling a claim, in exchange for consideration or another benefit, except for an institutional entity. For example, attorneys, appraisers, doctors, auto repair shops, surveyors, and installers or suppliers of security systems will be considered service providers.
3. Contract with a Service Provider
A. An insurance agent who refers a client to a service provider, recommends a service provider to the client, or is involved in selecting a service provider (hereinafter—Customer Referral), will act solely in the client's best interests and in accordance with his or her professional judgment.
B. An insurance agent shall not receive any compensation or other benefit, whether directly or indirectly, including from an institutional entity, for referring a client to a service provider.
c. An institutional entity shall not provide an insurance agent with any compensation or other benefit, whether directly or indirectly, for referring a client to a service provider.
4. Scope
The provisions of this circular shall apply to insurance agents and institutional entities.
5. First
This circular takes effect on the date of its publication.
Yadin Anatbi
Commissioner of Capital Markets, Insurance, and Savings
A client from the Haim Kalir & Co. website'