7 Cheshvan, 5760
October 17, 1999
Property and Casualty Insurance Circular 99/5
To
Insurance Company Executives
Hello,
Subject: Auto Insurance (Property) – Reduction of Insurance Benefits in the Event of a Total Loss
Over the past two years, we have received numerous public inquiries regarding the reduction of insurance benefits paid to policyholders with comprehensive auto insurance in cases of total loss or constructive total loss of the vehicle. This is despite the fact that the parameters taken into account when calculating the reduced insurance benefits were not considered when setting the insurance premiums. Furthermore, the insurers did not inform the policyholders in advance that they would reduce the vehicle’s value in the event of a claim, as noted above.
After reviewing the complaints with the various insurance companies and receiving their responses—both to the specific complaints and to the draft circular distributed to all insurance companies—and after it became clear that this is a deficiency found in many insurance companies, I hereby order, pursuant to my authority under Section 62(a) of the Insurance Business Supervision Law, 5741–1981, that the deficiency be corrected, generally, as detailed below:
1. The insurer shall inform the insured, at the time the insurance proposal is made, of the price list used to determine the value of the vehicle on the date the insurance contract is entered into and for the purpose of paying insurance benefits upon the occurrence of an insured event (hereinafter: "the price list"). The price list shall also be specified on the insurance details page.
In this regard: The vehicle’s "list price" – the value of the specific insured vehicle (such as: type of transmission, accessories, and other additions installed in the vehicle), without taking into account special variables that affect the vehicle’s value, such as: previous ownership, accident history, mileage, and exceptional or special wear and tear.
2. The insurer shall notify the insured, at the time of the insurance offer, of the total reduction (or increase) rate, based on the price list, resulting from specific variables to be detailed (hereinafter: "the deviation rate"). This deviation rate shall be used to reduce (or increase) the vehicle’s value in the price list for the purpose of calculating the insurance benefits to be paid in the event of a total loss or constructive total loss. The variables and the deviation rate will be specified on the insurance details page.
3. If the insurer has not notified the insured of the deviation rate as specified in Section 2, the value of the vehicle as listed in the price list shall apply for the purpose of calculating the insurance benefits, as stated in Section 1, which shall be deemed the "insurance amount" as defined in Section 56(a) of the Insurance Contract Law, 5741–1981.
4. When settling a claim, the insurer may not take into account any factors other than those specified in the insurance policy, except for a decrease in value resulting from an accident that occurred during the insurance period, prior to the insured event in which total loss (or constructive total loss), at the rate actually determined for such depreciation.
5. During the insurance proposal stage, the insurer shall ensure full disclosure of the insurance premiums it requires (the premium required by that insurer to cover the vehicle’s value, as specified in Section 2 of this circular) in comparison to the standard insurance premiums (the premium required by that insurer to cover the vehicle’s value as listed in the price list, as specified in Section 1 of this circular)—in accordance with the provisions of Section 55(b)(5) of the Supervision Law.
The provisions of this circular shall apply to all insurance contracts—both new and renewed—whose coverage period begins on January 1, 2000.
Best regards,
Tzipi Smad
Insurance Commissioner
The State of Israel
Ministry of Finance – Capital Markets, Insurance, and Savings Division