Jerusalem, 27 Cheshvan 5759
November 16, 1998
To
Officials in Charge of Public Inquiries at Insurance Companies
Subject: The Insurer's Obligation to Notify the Insured of Its Position Regarding the Claim
1. Our unit recently received a public complaint in which the complainant filed a claim with an insurance company but, despite numerous contacts with the company, did not receive a written statement of the company’s position regarding his claim.
2. Instead of receiving written notice of the company’s position regarding the grounds for his claim, the complainant received various proposals aimed at settling the case. The amounts offered as part of the settlement were not accompanied by any explanation or details regarding the basis for calculating the proposed amount; worse still, the complainant was never informed of the insurance company’s position—that is, whether it accepted or rejected his claim.
3. An insured person or a third party filing a claim with the insurance company (hereinafter: 'the claimant") is entitled to and must receive, in writing, the insurance company’s full position regarding all grounds for the claim. Lengthy and varied explanations provided to the claimant—no matter how detailed or well-reasoned they may be during numerous long telephone conversations—do not alter the fact that without a written document setting forth the insurer’s position, the claimant cannot consult with professionals and, consequently, cannot plan his next steps.
4. When a claimant’s claim is denied, the insurer must specify all the grounds for denying the claim at the first available opportunity; if it fails to do so, the insurer may not raise, at a later date any additional grounds for denial that it could have raised at the first opportunity.
5. In order for the claimant to address the insurer’s arguments rejecting his claim—and perhaps even succeed in persuading the insurer to change its position—he must receive a detailed written statement of the insurer’s position. This need becomes even more pressing when the claimant’s claim is accepted only in part. In such a case, if the insurer attempts to settle the claim through a settlement agreement, the claimant has no way to evaluate and consider the offer received from the insurer, since he lacks the information that guided the insurer in making that offer—information that is important and essential for deciding whether to accept a settlement agreement.
6. A notice to this effect was sent by us to the insurer. Please be advised that this is our position of principle on the matter; therefore, similar complaints received by our unit will be handled and resolved in accordance with the following and will be deemed "justified" complaints.
Sincerely,
Rachel Ratovitz, Attorney at Law
Senior Deputy Commissioner for Capital Markets, Insurance, and Savings
Copy: Ms. Tzipi Smad – Insurance Supervisor and Commissioner of Capital Markets, Insurance, and Savings
Mr. and Mrs. Last – CEO of the Association of Insurance Companies
Ms. Erit Shani, Attorney at Law – Capital Markets, Insurance, and Savings Division, Public Inquiries Unit