In most cases, insurance companies’ claims focus on the fact that the insured breached an obligation imposed on them by the policy or by law. However, it is important to note that an insurance contract is not an ordinary contract. In most cases, a breach of an obligation imposed on the insured does not preclude the insured’s rights. Below are several examples that illustrate this rule.
Failure to Activate Protective Measures
The policy sometimes requires the activation of security measures: an alarm, a connection to a monitoring center, and the like. However, in order to deny insurance benefits to a policyholder who did not activate security measures, it is not sufficient that the policyholder simply failed to do so. To be exempt from payment, the insurer must clear four hurdles.
As a first hurdle, the insurer must prove that the protection requirement was formulated clearly, prominently, and in detail, in close proximity to the relevant subject matter, and accompanied by explicit warnings that if the security measures are not implemented, the insured will not be entitled to insurance benefits.
The second hurdle is that activating the security measures would indeed have prevented the break-in. For example, the alarm would have alerted the security center staff, and they would have prevented the burglars from carrying out their plan.
In the third test, the insurer must prove that, even in exchange for a higher premium, no reasonable insurer would have agreed to waive the requirement to activate the security measures. Alternatively, to qualify for a partial exemption, the insurer may prove that if it had known the insured would not activate the security measures, it would have charged a higher premium.
In the fourth scenario, because the protective measures failed to function for reasons beyond the insured's control.
The insured failed to deposit his jewelry in a safe deposit box, even though the policy required this as a "prerequisite" for insurance coverage. The Supreme Court ruled that a "preliminary protection condition" violates the Insurance Law and ordered the insurer to pay the full insurance benefits after it failed to meet the third hurdle.
A truck driver pulled over to the side of the road to relieve himself. The truck was left running with the keys in the ignition and the Ituran system not activated. The truck was stolen. The policy required that the Ituran be activated whenever the truck was unoccupied. The insurer failed to prove that a reasonable insurer would not have insured the truck at any premium in the world had it known that the Ituran would not be activated. The insurer was ordered to pay because it failed to meet the third threshold.
The policy conditioned insurance coverage on "protecting the interior of the apartment with a properly functioning and active alarm system." The insured left his home for half an hour without activating the alarm. The court ruled that the insurer had not met the first threshold. The policy did not state that the alarm system must be activated around the clock, even when no one was home for a period of about half an hour.
The policy required that an alarm be activated as a precondition for coverage against burglary risks. The court ruled that the insured was entitled to insurance benefits even though the alarm had not been activated. The burglary damages can be included under the policy’s existing "all-risks" coverage. “After all, all-risks insurance covers loss and theft even without a break-in, both outside and inside the home, regardless of the cause.”.
In another case, the court was less lenient, and the failure to arm the alarm system resulted in the loss of insurance coverage. A couple left their apartment for two and a half hours without arming the alarm. Their apartment was broken into. The judge ruled that the alarm system is not merely a "decoration" in the apartment and must be activated whenever the apartment is unoccupied.
An insured person leaves the key in the ignition of his car and walks about five meters away from the vehicle toward a nearby ATM. While he is withdrawing money from the ATM, his car is stolen. Is he entitled to insurance benefits? The courts are divided on whether, in such a situation, the vehicle is considered unattended and the insured is required to activate security measures.
Breach of a Precondition
In the field of insurance, unlike in other areas of law, the insurer cannot make a policy provision a condition precedent. A condition precedent is a provision whose breach retroactively voids the contract. A provision in the policy stated that if the insured fails to provide the insurer, prior to a theft, with confirmation of the installation of security measures, then the policy is invalid. This is an example of a condition precedent, and the court struck it down. It is unacceptable for the insured to pay a premium, receive a signed policy, and install security measures, only to discover retroactively that he has no insurance coverage simply because he did not provide the insurer with proof of security measures.
In life insurance proposals, it is common to find a provision stipulating that the insurer’s liability is contingent upon the payment of the first premium. The court ruled that this provision is invalid. From the moment the insurance contract is concluded—such as when the agent confirms to the insured that coverage is in effect, and certainly when the insurer completes the underwriting of the proposal—the insured is covered, even if the first premium has not been paid, for any reason whatsoever.
An insured person who has sinned is still insured
The Supreme Court ruled that even an insured person who has acted wrongfully—that is, who has behaved inappropriately, with gross negligence, or even recklessly and carelessly—is entitled to full insurance benefits. Only an insured person who conspires to obtain insurance benefits—such as someone who sets their own house on fire or stages a break-in to claim insurance benefits—forfeits their rights.
Under this approach, the courts have ordered insurers to pay insurance benefits to a structural engineer who knowingly violated a safety standard, causing the house to collapse; to a woman who jumped out of her husband’s car during an argument with him; to a policyholder who left valuable items next to his wife while she was dozing on the beach, to a policyholder whose car was stolen using keys left in a bag on a beach towel, to a set designer who built the Maccabiah Bridge that collapsed, and in other such cases.
The Doctrine of Comparative Negligence in Insurance Law
There is a dispute among judges as to whether the insurer is entitled to deduct from the insurance benefits the proportion attributable to the insured’s negligence in causing the insured event.
The insured got out of the car, leaving it running with the key in the ignition, and went to the front right side of the car to inflate a tire. An unidentified person got into the driver's seat and stole the car.
The court ruled in favor of the insured and held that applying the principle of contractual fault in cases where the insured event occurred due to the insured’s negligence "is contrary to the very purpose underlying insurance law.".
The Supreme Court was set to hold a hearing on the matter. The Attorney General sought to intervene on behalf of the insured and informed the Supreme Court that the doctrine of contributory negligence under contract law is contrary to insurance law. As a result of this position, the insurer withdrew its stance and paid the full insurance benefits.
Following these remarks, the Commissioner issued a position paper. The insurance policy, the Commissioner states, protects the insured even against his own negligence. Therefore, releasing the insurer from liability in the event of the insured’s negligence, or limiting its liability to a reduced rate of benefits, defeats the fundamental purpose of the insurance policy.
In two separate cases, the insured individuals went to play basketball and left their car keys with their clothes—one near the basket, and the other in one of the stands. The court ruled that they had not forfeited their right to insurance benefits.
Policy Exclusions and Exceptions – Duty to Disclose and Verify
The policy sometimes contains an exclusion that denies insurance benefits under the circumstances specified in that exclusion. The court ruled that some exclusions are invalid—specifically, when the exclusion renders the coverage meaningless. Thus, the court ruled that the “young driver” exclusion in a policy sold to a young driver is invalid.
The exception clause: "A claim arising directly or indirectly and/or as a result of a back injury." The court ruled that the intent of the exclusion was to cover a condition that existed in the back prior to the policy’s issuance. There was no intent to exclude future back injuries that would occur from the start of the policy onward.
The insurer must prove that it informed the insured of the existence of the exclusion and even verified that the insured understood it. This obligation is known as the duty to inform and verify. Thus, a exclusion stipulating that diamonds not kept in a safe are not covered against robbery is invalid. The exclusion was listed on the inside pages of the policy, while coverage against robbery was listed on the first page. Such an exclusion, the court ruled, does not comply with the obligation to list exclusions prominently and in close proximity to the subject matter to which the exclusion relates.
Shoppers walked out of a store with a piece of jewelry. This act is considered theft rather than a burglary. The insurer relied on a policy exclusion stating that "theft not involving a break-in" is not covered. The court ordered the insurer to pay, because the policy had not been provided to the insured prior to the theft and the insurer failed to prove that the insured was aware of the exclusion.
The travel insurance policy excluded coverage for pregnancy-related issues. During a cruise in the Caribbean, the insured experienced severe, persistent nausea. After her condition worsened, she was admitted to a hospital, where she was informed that she was pregnant. The insurer refused to cover the hospitalization expenses due to the pregnancy exclusion. The judge ruled that the travel agent who sold the insurance failed to draw the insured’s attention to the fact that medical expenses related to pregnancy were not covered under the policy; therefore, the exclusion was invalid.
The insurance certificate sent by the insurer to the Income Tax Authority employees covered under its group insurance policy did not state that riding a motorcycle was not covered. The court ruled that it was not sufficient for the exclusion to appear in the policy held at the offices of the Accountant General, and ordered the insurer to pay the insured who was injured while riding his motorcycle.
For more information, see A Guide for Claimants Seeking Insurance Benefits, A Guide for Long-Term Care Patients וA Guide for Victims of Traffic Accidents Issued by our firm.