The State of Israel
Ministry of Finance—Capital Markets, Insurance, and Savings Division
23 Shevat 5775
February 12, 2015
Case No. 2015-5198
To
Insurance Company Executives
Hello,
Subject: Ruling on a Point of Principle Regarding the Equal Rights for People with Disabilities Act
In accordance with the provisions of Section 19(h)(1) of the Equal Rights for People with Disabilities Law, 5758-1998 (hereinafter: "The Law") If an insurer decides to treat the insured differently, as defined by law, or if an insurer refuses to insure a person, the insurer shall provide the insured with a reasoned written notice containing a summary of the database, if the insurer relied on it in making the decision, as well as a summary of the information on which the decision was based. Notwithstanding the foregoing, an insurer may provide the reasons for its decision and a summary of the information and data, as detailed below, through the insurer’s physician.
An investigation into public inquiries received by the Capital Markets Division, Insurance and Savings Division, it was found that in certain cases, insurance companies fail to provide a reasoned notice to a policyholder with a disability when he or she is treated differently, or to a person with a disability whom the insurance company has refused to insure, as required.
By virtue of my authority under Section 62 of the Financial Services Supervision (Insurance) Law, 5741-1981, I hereby order that an insurance company provide a policyholder with a disability who has been treated differently, as defined by law, or a person with a disability whom the company has refused to insure, a reasoned written notice stating that the insurance company’s decision was based on its assessment that the specific insurance risk arising from the disability is greater than the insurance risk of persons who do not have that disability. The notice shall also include a summary of at least one of the following: the actuarial data, statistical data, medical information, or other information regarding the increase in the specific insurance risk, which formed the basis for the insurance company’s decision, as well as a summary of the information on which it relied with respect to that individual (such as: a reference to two professional articles or a reference to reinsurer guidelines regarding underwriting conditions on which the company based its decision).
For example, if an insurance company has refused to provide health insurance to a person who has a permanent and total disability or who suffers from chronic renal failure to the extent that he or she qualifies as a 'person with a disability' under the law —it must provide that person with a reasoned written notice stating that it has refused to insure them due to their condition, and must attach the information on which its decision was based: a summary of the data sources, if the insurance company relied on them in making its decision, as well as a summary of the information on which it was based. In its reasoning, the company may refer to a scientific article in the field of medicine, relevant statistical information, a relevant medical opinion or one specific to the case, or guidelines from a reinsurer as mentioned above, from which it can be inferred that a person with a complete and permanent disability or suffering from chronic renal failure poses a higher risk than a person not in that condition, or that, due to their condition, there is a greater likelihood that such a person will require the coverage included in the health insurance policy than is the case for another insured person not in that condition.
It should be clarified that the notice will also include the details specified in Section 19la(g)(2) of the Act and will be sent within the time limit set forth in Section 19la(g)(3) of the Act.
It should be noted that, as of the date of this ruling, proceedings had begun on a motion to certify a class action regarding the Equal Rights for People with Disabilities Law in Class Action Case No. 43232-05-12, S.Y.D.H. et al. v. Migdal et al. (hereinafter: 'The Request"). This ruling does not grant the class members the relief sought in the petition, as it addresses the conduct of insurance companies toward people with disabilities, so that they are provided with full notice as required by law; therefore, I have decided to issue this ruling, notwithstanding the commencement of proceedings on the motion in question.”.
Leora Hirschhorn, Attorney at Law
Deputy Insurance Commissioner
Copy:
Dorit Slinger, Insurance Commissioner
Attorney Assi Klein, Legal Department, Ministry of Finance
Sharona Feldman, Director of the Health and Long-Term Care Insurance Department