At the age of 68, Sarah went on a trip to Hungary. The night before she was due to return to Israel, while staying in Budapest, she fell and was injured. Instead of ending her vacation and returning home, Sarah found herself hospitalized in Budapest.
After spending several days in the hospital abroad, Sarah returned to Israel. Here, she was admitted to Shaare Zedek Medical Center. From there, she was transferred to Herzog Medical Center, where she remained for 25 days.
Several years earlier, Sarah had purchased two personal accident insurance policies from Direct Insurance. The policies promised insurance benefits for hospitalization due to an accident. When Sarah sought to receive her compensation, Direct Insurance referred her to the insurance companies’ standard escape clause: the fine print of the policy. There, in the “Definitions” section, Direct Insurance stated that hospitalization does not include admission to a rehabilitation facility or a rehabilitation ward in a general hospital. “Since you were hospitalized for rehabilitation, you are not entitled to anything,” the claims adjusters told Sarah.
Sarah didn't give up; she sued Direct Insurance in the Ramla Magistrate's Court. Her lawsuit was filed with Judge Zivan Elimi.
Judge Elimi reviewed the policies and found that, according to their terms, Direct Insurance was in the right. Even if Herzog is a general hospital, that does not help the insured. The policy also excluded hospitalization in a rehabilitation ward within a general hospital.
Judge Elimi could have stopped at this point and dismissed Sarah’s claim. Unfortunately, this is how many judges operate, treating the insurance policy as a sublime theological text handed down at Mount Sinai. Not so Judge Zivan Elimi. In his view, in insurance law, the question is not merely what is written in the policy. The question is also how the policyholder was made aware of the terms when the insurance was sold to her.
Section 3 of the Insurance Contract Law, as Justice Elimi noted in the Direct Insurance case, requires that every exclusion be listed immediately next to the coverage it qualifies, or be specifically highlighted. The logic behind the law is simple. An insurance company may not promise coverage on one page of the policy and then, elsewhere—in a remote and obscure location—render that promise meaningless through an exclusion. The insured must be able to understand, without any special effort and without having to search through the pages of the policy, what the policy covers and what it excludes.
In this case, the judge ruled that Direct Insurance had not met any of these requirements with regard to the first policy. The exception was included in the Definitions section, some distance from the appendix that guaranteed compensation for hospitalization, without any emphasis and without even a reference to the section where the exception was listed.
In the second policy, the exception was highlighted, the judge acknowledged. On the face of it, Direct Insurance complied with the requirement to highlight it. However, in this case, Direct Insurance failed to comply with the provisions of Insurance Supervisor Circular 2001/9 regarding proper disclosure. This circular was issued to make the process of selling health insurance more transparent and understandable. The circular imposes an additional obligation on the insurance company beyond the requirement for prominence. It must include, in every policy it provides to the insured, an overview of the insurance plan purchased, with a reference to the policy’s exclusions and exceptions. In this case, Judge Elimi ruled that the disclosure form provided to Sarah at the time of purchasing the policy contained no mention whatsoever that rehabilitative hospitalization was not covered. Therefore, the judge ruled that even with regard to the second policy—in which the exclusion was clearly highlighted—the company is not entitled to rely on it.
Judge Zivan Elimi therefore ordered Direct Insurance to pay Sarah the insurance benefits for 25 days of hospitalization, as well as 10,000 shekels in attorney’s fees. However, the judge rejected her request for special interest, because the wording of the policy supported the company’s position and, in his view, indicated a genuine dispute.
In my humble opinion, Judge Elimi’s precise ruling missed the mark regarding the purpose of the Insurance Contract Law and the Insurance Supervisor’s circular. The insurance company, with all its vast capabilities, is well aware of what it must do to comply with its duty of transparency. If, when the insured contacts the company after suffering a disaster, the insurance company discovers that the duty of transparency was not fulfilled as required, it must immediately take responsibility for its failures and pay the insured the insurance benefits. If, instead of acting fairly from the outset, the insurance company only pays what it was obligated to pay from the beginning at the end of a protracted legal process, it is creating a dispute in bad faith and must pay the insured special interest as required by law.